What is UPS? UPS vs NPS – Which is better for you?

What is UPS?

What is UPS? UPS vs NPS; Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw recently explained a new pension scheme in 10 simple points. Here’s the breakdown of the key features:

1. Assured Pension: Retirees will get 50% of their average basic pay as a pension for at least 25 years of service.
2. Government Contribution: The government will increase its contribution to 18.5%, while employees will not have to contribute more.
3. Assured Pension to family: If a pensioner passes away, their family will receive 60% of the pension.
4. Assured Minimum Pension: Retirees will get a minimum pension of Rs 10,000 per month after 10 years of service.
5. Inflation Protection: Pensions will be linked to inflation to ensure retirees’ income keeps pace with the rising cost of living.
6. Lump-Sum Payment: Retirees will receive a lump-sum payment at retirement, in addition to gratuity.
7. Universal Pension System (UPS) Provisions: Past retirees will also benefit from UPS, with arrears paid with interest.
8. UPS as an Option: UPS will be available as an option for existing and future employees, with the choice being final once made.
9. Implementation: The Central Government is implementing UPS for 23 lakh employees, with the same model applicable to State Governments.
10. Potential Impact: If State Governments also adopt UPS, over 90 lakh government employees could benefit from this new pension scheme.

In crux, the new scheme aims to provide better financial security for retirees and their families, with increased contributions, assured pensions, and inflation protection.

UPS vs NPS

Let us understand the difference between the NPS and UPS.

The Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) has recently been introduced by the central government, aimed at providing a mix of defined benefit and defined contribution features for government employees subscribed to the New Pension Scheme (NPS). This scheme offers a guaranteed pension income based on a percentage of the average basic pay drawn over the last 12 months, giving some level of assurance to retirees about their post-retirement financial security.

The aspect of guaranteed income is one of the main distinctions between the UPS and NPS. While, the NPS provides potential equity market returns, the UPS offers a fixed monthly pension amount that can be substantial for many government employees. This aspect has divided opinion among experts, with some advocating for sticking with the NPS for growth potential and others suggesting that the guaranteed income provided by UPS is a valuable asset for securing basic post-retirement lifestyle needs.

The contribution structure of the UPS involves both the employee and the employer (central government) making contributions towards the corpus. Employees contribute 10% of their basic pay plus dearness allowance, while the government’s contribution has been increased to 18.5% under the UPS, compared to 14% under the NPS. This increment is aimed at ensuring the scheme is fully-funded and sustainable in the long run.

However, the management of the corpus and investments under the UPS is a critical factor that will determine its success and sustainability. A separate guarantee reserve fund has been established, with 8.5% of the government’s contribution directed towards this fund. The purpose of this reserve fund is to cover any potential shortfalls in meeting pension commitments, ensuring that retirees receive their entitled benefits without additional burden on the government. To maintain the sustainability of the scheme, strong governance and prudent investment decisions will be essential, especially given the long-term nature of pension liabilities and the changing landscape of retirement planning.

The implementation and administration of the UPS raise some questions and concerns that have yet to be clarified. It remains unclear who will manage the scheme, with speculation that it may fall under the purview of the Pension Fund Regulatory Authority of India (PFRDA). Additionally, the tax implications of the UPS, including how pension income and lump sum payments will be taxed, are still unclear and await further clarification from the government.

Taxes in UPS vs NPS

In terms of taxation, experts anticipate that pension income under the UPS will be subject to income-tax rates. Existing tax benefits, such as the tax-free lump sum payment of 60% of the accumulated corpus at retirement, provided by the NPS may or may not apply to the UPS. Further details on the tax treatment of UPS benefits are awaited, leaving some uncertainty among potential participants regarding their post-retirement tax obligations.

Conclusion

Overall, the introduction of the Unified Pension Scheme presents an opportunity for government employees subscribed to the NPS to consider their retirement planning options and weigh the benefits of guaranteed income against potential market returns. With careful management of the corpus and prudent investment strategies, the UPS has the potential to provide a reliable source of post-retirement income for employees, ensuring financial security and peace of mind in their later years.

Stay tuned for further blogs. Subscribe to our website and join our telegram channel – Click Here to Join Now